Hello readers! This is my first polish post so I have high expectations and hope that everyone enjoys the comparison between these 5 pretty polishes. I will always try to be as descriptive as possible. Occasionally, I'll have access to a light box to get better photos. All photos were taken using the new iPhone 4S.
My 5 choices I compared:
- Barielle's 'Brown Sparkles' - A warm silvery taupe melted molten foil
- OPI's 'DESIGNER...DE BETTER!' - A mostly silver foil/glitter with sparse ultra fine reddish-pink glitter
- MAC's 'SOIRÉE' - A copper rose-gold silver foil glitter
- Orly's 'RAGE' - A pinkish silver foil glitter (slightly less fine than MAC's 'SOIRÉE')
- OPI's 'ROSY REFLECTION' - A cool pinkish-purple silver foil glitter (similar to that of Orly's 'RAGE')
Photos of polish in natural sunlight:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7121e/7121e3576050afd6be4da195b99c6fe6a3d15039" alt="" |
Barielle 'Brown Sparkles', OPI 'DESIGNER...DE BETTER!', MAC 'SOIRÉE, Orly 'RAGE', and OPI 'ROSY REFLECTION' |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0af46/0af4694fb47cfb97fedd90162919d07b7e9fdbc7" alt="" |
Barielle 'Brown Sparkles', OPI 'DESIGNER...DE BETTER!', MAC 'SOIRÉE, Orly 'RAGE', and OPI 'ROSY REFLECTION' |
Photos of polish in artificial light (in bathroom):
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0be9b/0be9bfcec638dbfeda775ee6b6546a047c1f6194" alt="" |
Barielle 'Brown Sparkles', OPI 'DESIGNER...DE BETTER!', MAC 'SOIRÉE, Orly 'RAGE', and OPI 'ROSY REFLECTION' |
Photos of polish indoors with flash:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/036ad/036ad5ab01fded00b71af5957c9dfb0ed3832feb" alt="" |
Barielle 'Brown Sparkles', OPI 'DESIGNER...DE BETTER!', MAC 'SOIRÉE, Orly 'RAGE', and OPI 'ROSY REFLECTION' |
Photos of polish outside in mostly shade (2 coats each):
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e0523/e0523755e63b8d7d59d306c29956e9a42ea0be9f" alt="" |
Thumb - OPI 'Rosy Reflection' | Index - Orly 'Rage' | Middle - MAC 'Soirée' | Ring - OPI 'Designer...de better' | Pinky - Barielle 'Brown Sparkles' |
Photos of polish outside in the sun (2 coats each):
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/117d5/117d55cc3bb191303196a1ad50daf9ea81f6dbb6" alt="" |
Thumb - OPI 'Rosy Reflection' | Index - Orly 'Rage' | Middle - MAC 'Soirée' | Ring - OPI 'Designer...de better' | Pinky - Barielle 'Brown Sparkles' |
Photos of polish outside 1/2 shade 1/2 sun (2 coats each):
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/26982/269824328e6b1792efbdc533906190e96b202d49" alt="" |
Thumb - OPI 'Rosy Reflection' | Index - Orly 'Rage' | Middle - MAC 'Soirée' | Ring - OPI 'Designer...de better' | Pinky - Barielle 'Brown Sparkles' |
Photos of polish indoors with artificial light:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4de1d/4de1d9e77bfcc36555eb0de62fea156331c166a6" alt="" |
Thumb - OPI 'Rosy Reflection' | Index - Orly 'Rage' | Middle - MAC 'Soirée' | Ring - OPI 'Designer...de better' | Pinky - Barielle 'Brown Sparkles' |
Overall what I thought of each polish:
- Barielle's 'Brown Sparkles' - Nice thick formula, covered almost opaque on the first try, I really liked the brush. The color didn't have very noticeable glitter, appeared most like a foil or chrome polish.
- OPI's 'Designer...de Better' - Went on sheer at first, covered pretty good after two and would be perfect after three. Offered by far the most light reflective properties and the hints of reddish-pink glitter were quite noticeable. More of a glittery/foil combination. Really shines!
- MAC's 'Soirée' - A fine glitter foil, again I liked the formula and the brush. It covered almost as good as the Barielle. Not my favorite of the bunch which sucks because I paid a pretty penny for it. Definitely the most 'copper' hued out of the five.
- Orly's 'Rage' - The glitter appearance is almost identical to that of the MAC shade, but much much more pink. The pinkest hued of all the shades, I'd say it's a bright silvery-pink foil with fine glitter. It covered similar to the MAC but the brush strokes were most apparent in this one.
- OPI's 'Rosy Reflection' - A pretty rare shade I had high hopes for and I'd say I like it a good bit but it definitely needs 3 coats just like the other OPI shade I swatched. A more glitter foil with a purple-pink hue. Gorgeous color!
All and all I really enjoyed all 5 shades (good thing since I own them all, huh?!) but my favorite is... just kidding I can't decide. Oddly, the OPI's are the most interesting to me but the Barielle formula and brush are a winning combination! Does anyone own any of these shades? I recommend all of them! (Of course, right!)
Thanks all for reading!
♥ Cheers,
Bridget